In this post I am going to explain how and why prosecutors and not victims are the ones that decide when charges are filed in a criminal case.
When someone has been harmed by the actions of another, it can rise to criminal conduct if it was done with intent to commit an illegal act or to inflict harm on the victim.
However, not every apparent criminal act is prosecuted for a variety of reasons, foremost being a lack of evidence to convict the alleged perpetrator.
What Are The Obligations Of The Prosecutor?
A prosecutor must weigh whether the evidence at hand is sufficient to convict the accused on all elements of the offense by the standard of beyond a reasonable doubt.
A prosecutor is also presumably obligated to pursue justice and the truth without influence from the victim, media or community. The prosecutor also has a duty to protect victims from undue harm and to protect their rights as well as to hold the guilty accountable.
Factors That a Prosecutor Considers in Whether to Bring Charges:
- Doubts about the evidence supporting the accused’s guilt
- The adequacy of incriminating evidence or whether it is admissible
- Whether financial restitution is available and adequate
- The mental status or credibility of the victim or accuser
- Whether such offenses have been routinely not enforced
- If the harm to the victim was negligible
- Plausibility of the accused’s alibi
- If prosecution would result in undue hardship to the victim
- If the offense is relatively minor
- If the victim is non-cooperative
- If the accused is being cooperative
Any of these factors alone or in combination can be persuasive in whether a prosecutor will decide to bring charges or not.
A key element in a prosecution are the police reports. They are usually the most relevant document in the prosecutor’s decision whether to press charges or not
They establish whether the elements of a crime are present and if the evidence found at the scene or which may lead to other evidence is adequate, credible and legally obtained.
Who Writes The Police Report?
Police reports are prepared by the arresting officer with input from other officers participating in the arrest and investigation and approved by a superior.
Because these officers are usually the first responders, the report can include the sights, sounds, smells, stains and the demeanor of the victim, accused and witnesses.
What is Included In The Police Report?
The reports are based on notes compiled by the officer at the scene or shortly thereafter and also contain
- Witness statements,
- Measurements of evidence such as skid marks,
- Discovery of potentially incriminating evidence and conclusions.
Are There Additional Reports?
Later investigations will follow up on the initial report, sometimes verifying what was found or discrediting it.
What the officer found and observed at the scene can color a prosecutor’s perceptions on the innocence or guilt as well as the honesty or deception of the parties involved.
What Happens If The Police Report Is Not Accurate?
If the officer omitted a key piece of evidence that was later discovered and found to be potentially exculpatory or even incriminating, failed to document that proper protocol was followed in the chain of evidence or did not follow proper police procedures, then the defense can seize on the improprieties and possibly
Retaining a criminal defense attorney following an arrest and before charges are filed is a sound idea. If you feel that charges are imminent and have not yet been arrested, then promptly meeting with your attorney is equally as important.
What Your Attorney Will Need To Know?
Your lawyer will need to know as much as possible about your situation, the basis of the potential charges that you face and the evidence supporting them before meeting with the prosecutor handling your case.
In some cases, arrests are made based on faulty identification or the ulterior motives of someone like an estranged spouse or intimate partner. Misunderstandings are not uncommon.
Still, going to speak to a prosecutor alone is never a good idea who may not be willing to speak to you anyway unless you are represented and accompanied by counsel.
Do You Have An Alibi?
If you have an alibi and can prove you were elsewhere at the time of the crime, your attorney can corroborate this and then schedule a meeting with the prosecutor to discuss.
You might use this tactic if you can demonstrate that an accuser is mentally unsound or has a motive for alleging you committed some wrongdoing and the evidence is not credible or cannot be corroborated.
Possibly Making A Deal With The Prosecution
In matters where you may be charged with a serious crime where others are involved, you might consider a plea bargain cooperating with the prosecution.
Your offer could include your testimony or providing of documentary evidence against other culpable parties in return for either having no charges filed, being granted immunity from prosecution or promised a greatly reduced sentence.
There Are Different Types Of Immunity
Be aware that there are different types of immunity, if it is offered, and that you could still be charged based on other evidence. Your defense attorney needs to explain this to you and assess the current and potential incriminating evidence against you.
We Can Help
If you are seeking an attorney to represent you in a criminal matter pleasse contact Aizman Law Firm for a confidential consultation at 818-351-9555.